News   GLOBAL  |  Apr 02, 2020
 11K     0 
News   GLOBAL  |  Apr 01, 2020
 43K     0 
News   GLOBAL  |  Apr 01, 2020
 6.8K     0 
This can't be a tragedy..... it must be satire:

1770243377296.png
 
While fixing photos shot in 2012, I fill in missing info and streaming tags with two things jump out at me for them. All LRT tracks I have seen in Europe Have a groove rail system something TTC had until there was no supplier in NA who produce them. TTC gets special ones for switches from X.

Alstom Citadis is their main platform for LRV's with over 8,000's built so far in various styles and setup. The Citadis Spirit are only used in NA with Ottawa and the Finch line that has them in service at this time.

The profile of Europe rail head is slight different than NA rails. I don't know if the Ottawa Lines, the Finch Line and the Hurontario Line are using NA rails or Europe rails.

Since Alstom is sticking to the Citadis platform for the bogies for NA, the bogies will have an issue with NA rails without grooves for straight tacks as well curves that don't have groove rail encased in the road or ROW. One reason why al lot of the Hurontario line is been ripped up and rebuilt to meet Alstom bogies requirements. I haven't seen any non encase rails in Europe for any streetcar/tram/LRV system.

Nice France 2012
8022852431_5f394b8eee_o.jpg


No overhead area In The Place Masséna (1844)
8022866146_afecfba8e2_o.jpg


Lignes d'Azur 23 Alstom Citadis 302 35m (2006) LRV/Tram On Nice Tramway In The Place Masséna (1844) With Pantograph Down. Takes 10 seconds at each stations to change power source.
8022871491_77d0ca145c_o.jpg
 
But the fundamental design is very different.
AFAIK, the Flexity Freedoms have been out of production for 5 years, to restart production would be infeasible at this point. It's not surprising that Alstom would push their own rolling stock family (which are usually quite good, except for the Spirits). Hamilton's LRT will likely be stuck with the defective Spirits as well... The province seems to be gearing up for Alstom Citadis streetcars as well (I speculate). I can only hope that they're not derived from the Spirits.

If you zoom in on the tram below, it's clearly an Alstom Citadis, dare I say, it looks identical to the Ottawa Spirits...
1770305852029.png
1770305972106.png
https://www.metrolinx.com/en/projec...t-were-building/riverside-leslieville-station
 
AFAIK, the Flexity Freedoms have been out of production for 5 years, to restart production would be infeasible at this point. It's not surprising that Alstom would push their own rolling stock family (which are usually quite good, except for the Spirits). Hamilton's LRT will likely be stuck with the defective Spirits as well... The province seems to be gearing up for Alstom Citadis streetcars as well (I speculate). I can only hope that they're not derived from the Spirits.

If you zoom in on the tram below, it's clearly an Alstom Citadis, dare I say, it looks identical to the Ottawa Spirits...
View attachment 712985View attachment 712986https://www.metrolinx.com/en/projec...t-were-building/riverside-leslieville-station
That's not true. The TTC ordered 60 to augment their fleet and there have been Edmonton cars being built as well.
 
That's not true. The TTC ordered 60 to augment their fleet and there have been Edmonton cars being built as well.
I think you're mistaking the Flexity Outlook streetcars with the Freedoms for the 3 LRT lines in Canada:

Edmonton received its last Flexity Freedom for the Valley Line in Q1 2021. They ordered trams for the Valley Line extension from Hyundai Rotem in November 2021:

All evidence points to the Flexity Freedoms being out of production, since the last were delivered in early 2021.
 
Any adjustor (or Six Sigma grad) would say there is an a reasonable level of expected faults (i.e. death) in any system or process. Zero is an impossible goal, and thus making it an unreachable objective, where by its binary nature means you fail every day no matter how hard you try, results eventually in apathy. Instead we need to set a reasonable number of faults (deaths and injuries), ideally by looking at the safest systems in the world, and use them as the goal.

Yep, Vision Zero is an incredibly emotionally charged and political propaganda speak. It has nothing to do with reason or logic. Its an emotional response to the assumption that it would be immoral to allow for absolutely any deaths ever, no matter how random and rare they were.

There's only one way to get to Vision Zero, if we all stay home and lock our doors. Total curfew.
 
AFAIK, the Flexity Freedoms have been out of production for 5 years, to restart production would be infeasible at this point. It's not surprising that Alstom would push their own rolling stock family (which are usually quite good, except for the Spirits). Hamilton's LRT will likely be stuck with the defective Spirits as well... The province seems to be gearing up for Alstom Citadis streetcars as well (I speculate). I can only hope that they're not derived from the Spirits.

If you zoom in on the tram below, it's clearly an Alstom Citadis, dare I say, it looks identical to the Ottawa Spirits...
View attachment 712985View attachment 712986https://www.metrolinx.com/en/projec...t-were-building/riverside-leslieville-station
Couldn't they just order the regular citadis for the streetcar fleet? I had thought that the spirit was modded for more subway-like service, and the mods wouldn't be needed on the streetcar network.
 

Back
Top