News   GLOBAL  |  Apr 02, 2020
 11K     0 
News   GLOBAL  |  Apr 01, 2020
 43K     0 
News   GLOBAL  |  Apr 01, 2020
 6.8K     0 
I think those holes were created when the center stanchions were removed from the H6 and H5 cars. I can't recall if any of the older Hawkers had them removed as well around that time.

This was a recommendation to the TTC after Russell Hill in 1995. Emergency services had a heck of a time getting stretchers and injured people through the cars.
I am not aware of any H6s ever having their center stanchions removed. Not even all of the H5s were done - to my knowledge, it was limited to a handful of cars, including 5755, 5784-87, 5799, and the T1 prototype 5796. If you go onto Flickr and type in "Hawker-Siddeley H5 interior", you will see photos of many cars from the last few years of service still with the center stanchions.

And here is 5707, the last surviving car, taken in 2022:)

1721476402303.jpeg


I like these interiors a lot better than the sterile, waiting room grey of the T1s. It's a shame the TTC didn't wake up and start caring about their history until long after these were nixed.
 
I am not aware of any H6s ever having their center stanchions removed. Not even all of the H5s were done - to my knowledge, it was limited to a handful of cars, including 5755, 5784-87, 5799, and the T1 prototype 5796. If you go onto Flickr and type in "Hawker-Siddeley H5 interior", you will see photos of many cars from the last few years of service still with the center stanchions.

And here is 5707, the last surviving car, taken in 2022:)

View attachment 581925

I like these interiors a lot better than the sterile, waiting room grey of the T1s. It's a shame the TTC didn't wake up and start caring about their history until long after these were nixed.

And you can definitely see what I am referring to in that photo.

AoD
 
  • Like
Reactions: T3G
I think those holes were created when the center stanchions were removed from the H6 and H5 cars. I can't recall if any of the older Hawkers had them removed as well around that time.

This was a recommendation to the TTC after Russell Hill in 1995. Emergency services had a heck of a time getting stretchers and injured people through the cars.
Yet plenty of brand new modern trains around the world still have center poles, like this one in Warsaw (and right infront of the doorways no less). In fact, it was the older 81-717s that lacked center poles before the newer trains came in with them. But the Hawkers are to blame here, got it.
And here is 5707, the last surviving car, taken in 2022:)
5707 better outlive us all:)
I like these interiors a lot better than the sterile, waiting room grey of the T1s.
Spot on, that design change always felt so backwards and such a downgrade.
It's a shame the TTC didn't wake up and start caring about their history until long after these were nixed.
I think we all know exactly why that is, in fact they always cared about their history EXCEPT while those were being nixed, whether it was around 2000 or the 2010s🤬 So now there's no point of them ever waking up at all because there's no more history left to speak of, and never will be again.
 
Last edited:
Europe subway cars not only had a centre pole, but 4 short gab bar on the in the middle section that really cut down aisle space
8255014899_04733b6cd4_b.jpg



Some systems had next to no seats from the door to the driver compartment as it was for standing and accessibility riders with nothing to hold onto
8255008475_c4dd0781cb_b.jpg
 
So now there's no point of them ever waking up at all because there's no more history left to speak of, and never will be again.
The TTC was not discontinued when those cars were retired. As long as time moves on, and the TTC keeps running, history will keep being created. Not saving anything else is spiteful and does the generations that follow us a disservice.
 
The TTC was not discontinued when those cars were retired. As long as time moves on, and the TTC keeps running, history will keep being created. Not saving anything else is spiteful and does the generations that follow us a disservice.
I couldn't care less if it's spiteful, it's the only fair thing to do now, there is NOTHING more spiteful and more of a disservice than turning around and saving everything else that came afterwards, none of which is in ANY way more special and worthy of saving than those cars that weren't saved. It's almost like the TTC might as well have been discontinued.

You know, you keep saying this (as well as "long live the T1s"), and then you have the nerve to tell me I'm writing "fictions" when I say that you and the ttc are trying to have everything else saved except those cars. I challenge you to look me in the eye and tell me again that this is all "fiction" and a "baseless conspiracy" and that there was never a personal vendetta against the Hawkers despite there being plenty enough evidence to the contrary.
 
Last edited:
Dude, you are literally responding to a post in which I wrote that it's a shame the cars didn't get saved. I can't even reminisce without you jumping me with your baseless conspiracy theories.

There is no conspiracy against the Hawkers. For much of the last 30 years, the TTC hasn't given a shit about their history. That's all there is to it. The Hawkers are hardly the only equipment that didn't get saved. Any assertions that single our the Hawkers (or accuse me of being against their preservation) are fictions and are getting really tiresome to read.
 
Last edited:
It was just another subway car…. Till it wasn’t now. There’s nothing unique with them when they retired. We would love to ride the G-1s and have a blast in the past (not in the scorching summer of course). The cost of keeping them alive is unaffordable.
 
Dude, you are literally responding to a post in which I wrote that it's a shame the cars didn't get saved.
Well, advocating that they save everything else (least of all the very things that replaced them and sent them to scrap) is not gonna right that wrong, is it? Quite the opposite actually. Any future generations for whom it would be a "disservice" to not save anything that came later would just have to deal with it the same way those who want to see the Hawkers saved are forced to deal with it.
The Hawkers are hardly the only equipment that didn't get saved.
And I'm still not buying your narrative that the vast majority of everything that ever ran in Toronto/area has gone fully extinct, because:

– NO streetcar has ever gone extinct ANYWHERE, literally the whole world is overflowing with historic streetcars, literally every city that ever had streetcars saved at least one (if not a lot more) of each type, and if there were any that weren't saved, they most likely were interchangeable enough with ones that were (feel free to prove me wrong)
– pretty much every bus you can think of that Toronto didn't save, has been saved somewhere else in North America, including Ontario, like I said before (luckily for me that includes the Orion V & VI with the far rear door; you said no D40/60 was saved except one by OPB, what about the ones picked up by Cullingford Coaches? are there any others that weren't scrapped yet? or even ones that are still in service?)
– if no one saves a Hawker and instead saves one (or both) of the current subway fleet, the Hawkers will be singled out completely, for the foreseeable future (at least until the T1 replacements are replaced themselves and presumably don't get saved) if not forever (the G2–4s don't count as they were hardly different than the G1s aside from the paint job and the body being made of aluminum rather than steel, otherwise the body was identical to the G1 and all other components interior-wise and under the hood were also virtually identical to the G1s; maybe the Tokyo Rose counts, unless another copy of it exists somewhere)

It was just another subway car…. Till it wasn’t now. There’s nothing unique with them when they retired.
Bullshit!
 
Last edited:
Well, advocating that they save everything else (especially the things that replaced them) is not gonna right that wrong, is it? Any future generations for whom it would be a "disservice" to not save anything that came later would just have to deal with it the same way those who want to see the Hawkers saved are forced to deal with it.
This right here is why I feel no sympathy for your position, and why I expect you are having a difficult time finding anyone else who does, either.

So because you didn't get what you want, now no one, from now on through to the end of time, shouldn't get what they want, either? These are thoughts you should keep inside your head, instead of broadcasting them online in search of sympathy. Imagine if the human race had applied this kind of self-interested thinking to righting any kind of historical ill. Humanity would've perished hundreds of years ago.

As I have told you before on numerous occasions, if you want to actually do something constructive to help the Hawker cause, start taking action. And by taking action I don't mean sending emails to politicians suggesting they save it, but canvassing people with like minded interests about buying 5707, and storing it, and pooling your money together for such a cause, when and if Picture Vehicles choose to dispose of it. And establish a relationship with them, so that if and when they decide they no longer need 5707, they think of you instead of the scrap man. Perhaps, when you have done this, you will appreciate how difficult volunteer led preservation actually is. It's easy to sit back and criticize HCRR and spout off asinine conspiracy theories from the comfort of your computer chair for not giving you what you want, but when you actually put your money where your mouth is, you'll find out it's not all sunshine and roses, and preservationists have to be more pragmatic and base their acquisition on criteria that is not "This one individual really wants us to."

Do something about it, or stop complaining.

not to mention that they're almost certainly survived by identical buses across the continent, since a D40 / Orion V / LFS / etc is what it is no matter what transit agency operates it. Not the case with the Hawkers, which are unique everywhere except maybe Ankara (and the fate of those is still largely unknown).
You must be confusing North America with a much smaller nation. If I am a bus fan from Toronto, and I am not obscenely wealthy, how often do you think I would have the opportunity to travel halfway across the continent to photograph a bus model that I like that was saved by some other city? The amount of people who would spend thousands of dollars on cross country trips, for no other reason than to see a historic bus, has to be a vanishingly small amount, and if they do it, they're likely to only do it once or twice in a lifetime.

They've got Orion Vs in New York, the only specimen in a public collection; D901s in Winnipeg, Vancouver, and Kennebunkport. NO D40 has been saved except for the one piece owned by Orion Picture Bus, which may or may not choose to allow public access to it, and may or may not choose to dispose of it if it becomes a liability to operate. There are no D60s, or Classic artics saved (the ones from Halifax, not the fishbowls with the classic front end). Again, if I am not obscenely wealthy, what good is this to me?

It was just another subway car…. Till it wasn’t now. There’s nothing unique with them when they retired.
They most certainly were unique in ways no other cars were that came before or after them.
Why are you guys making these assertions like they are anything but opinions?

There are as many opinions about any given vehicle as there are people who have ever had anything to do with them. Asserting as though it were a fact from a textbook that they are the greatest things in the world or the most boring things in the world is pretty inane. And again, as I said above, whether you personally think they are the bee's knees or the devil's armpits has no bearing whatsoever on whether they get preserved. You wouldn't think the PCCs were special if you were around at their peak when 750 of the things were running around - and the fact that someone really, really liked the PCC had no bearing on whether one got saved or not. Historical collections are not built on the capricious, vain opinions of foamers.

For the love of God, give it a rest.
 

Back
Top