It's really cool to have someone who worked on the project to chime in, but man it must kind of sting to see details you've worked on disappear from the final project. I assume the deep bronze cladding at the lower levels of the 'tower' floors have been scrapped. Shame, I really liked the stone colour and detailed cladding in the render
View attachment 738981
Thanks for the comment.
I wouldn't say 'sting,' per se, but its unfortunate to see certain elements removed or changed, after the fact. The detailing on the upper portion has been sloppily executed and now looks stunted unfortunately. The intent was to accentuate the verticality of the top box, broken by the smaller deep-ish reveals at the windows, with boxy elements surrounding them. Instead, it now has a deep horizontal shadow line, which runs along the length of the facade, breaking it up in squat horizontal sections. The colour choice of the metal cladding is also not great and does little to help the situation - it was meant to be more of lighter, almost creamy white/grey.
Lots of things change on a project over the duration of its design, planning and execution, but sadly it is often times not for the better. People paying for the product are ultimately the ones who make the final choices and, I am sure in the end that is what is most important to them, and not necessarily the built project.
While not the most prestigious or noteworthy project, it does have nice urban qualities and suits the context quite well - overall I believe the developers in this case had a positive intent and did go through the proper methods (community meetings, neighbourhood working groups, city planning etc.) to finally get this approved and built. I don't fully disagree with the concept that this building, is at least in part a catalyst for gentrification - these fears are valid and shouldn't be diminished nor ignored. Yet, cities are constantly changing and have been for decades, centuries, millennia and Toronto is no different. Chinatown has not always been Chinatown and will likely change over time into another neighbourhood filled with different demographics, socio-economic dynamics etc.