News   GLOBAL  |  Apr 02, 2020
 10K     0 
News   GLOBAL  |  Apr 01, 2020
 42K     0 
News   GLOBAL  |  Apr 01, 2020
 6K     0 

While that anecdotal evidence might be poor, it is often the only "evidence" given in many instances.

I agree with BrandonTO416, a subset of people who feel psychologically distraught cannot be a determinant for access - or restriction - to abortion.
 
Yea, I'm glad we're seeing some consensus on this very heated debate. Abortion is never a fun thing or something to be considered lightly, but those who tend to have problems are clearly women predisposed with other conditions. Overbearing family in regards to religion or women with bi-polar disorder, have schizophrenia, or even other more mild conditions tend to be the bulk of women who display problems.

And without repeating this too much, I can't tell you how many women who have problems having not had an abortion and spend their lives thinking what they could have made of themselves had they not had a baby at the wrong time.

I could probably find a hundred women who get depressed thinking about the "what ifs" on both sides, regardless whether they have abortions or not. You aren't going to find a great deal of statistics in this area because when people go to a psychiatrist or to counseling services, they go on terms that their problems are dealt with privately.

Depression and anxiety and the second guessing that goes along with it are disorders all people have irregardless of abortion. Abortion is just the scapegoat for existing psychological distress in the pro-life movement.

BTW, I have a great personal story for you. One of my cousins got married to a man before she graduated college. She became a devout born-again christian - totally southern US protestant style - in her college years. She happens to be one of the most anti-abortion people I know personally, and she now has three kids at age 32. She suffers from depression and takes many medications to control her feelings. I was talking to her once a family dinner last Christmas (one of the few times in a year I ever see her), and she was going on about how she feels down and she was second guessing herself saying she might should have waited until her 30's to have kids. I wasn't about to bring up the fact she could have an abortion and it wouldn't have been wrong. I already know her beliefs and there was no reason in bringing up something that would have created conflict, but the fact she said that was telling. Here a strong pro-life born again Christian was basically resenting having kids too early and if I had even uttered the words about choices and abortion would have set her off on a tangent of how wrong and immoral that is.

Too many women get married to the guy that they got pregnant with, not for the love between the couple, but "for the baby." That's not a healthy way to live a life in my opinion.

Chronic depression does exist for those who have babies before they are ready, again the best words I can use are there is no perfect. Pro-lifers need to find a new scapegoat, its not a good reason to be pro-life to say that people who have abortion have psychological problems. Its simply not the cause of psychological distress the vast majority of times.
 
Why is this a "great" personal story?In fact, it would have been wrong, apparently, in her mind.

It was a great story for the fact that it relates to the discussion, in a reverse reasoning sort of way. Here is a very pro-life, born again protestant Christian fundamentalist having an early life crisis, who is taking many anti-depressants, who was admitting to me that she wished she would have waited until she was in her 30's to have kids.

Yet she decided to marry a guy in her early 20's to stay firm with her religious beliefs and upbringing.

You tend to only hear stories about how distraught all the women are when they have abortions from the anti-abortion or pro-life movement, yet here is a glaring example of a total opposite case of someone who is facing some major mental problems dealing with her decision to marry a man she doesn't really love for the sake of children.

She was in nursing school, ended up completing her degree, and now she doesn't even work because of her personal circumstances.

Personal distress and anxiety can happen regardless if you choose to have an abortion or not. Its wrong to channel all of the negative energy towards abortion as the reason for one's distress.
 
But the story has nothing to do with abortion. You didn't mention abortion to her, and she didn't mention it to you. Sounds like it's a woman who's regretting or perhaps second-guessing some of her life choices, perhaps as part of a case of medically-defined depression or anxiety, combined with a crisis of faith, as she's probably wondering why a good, faithful person should end up in such circumstances.

We all do that, some badly, some not so much. I have twin girls, and when they were infants, when I was up through the night feeding two screaming babies there were times I'd wished they'd never been born, where I shouted that the little buggers had stolen my life and a whole host of nasty thoughts. But, once you're no longer in the moment, you get over it (sometimes with the help of a doctor, therapist and if necessary medication) and move on. One of the signs of maturity is excepting your circumstances and moving forward from there. That's what I did, basically saying to myself that my children did not ask to be conceived and born, so now it's my job (and my wife's) to raise. love and protect them.

The loving part, by the way, does not come naturally, as there were times in those dark, sleepless screaming hours when I hated the kids. One of the other twin mothers in our group told my wife and I that while everyone else is telling you having babies is so wonderful, you need to know the truth, which is, with twins or more, it's a terrible, soul and marriage crushing time, but that you will survive this time, and look back on it with a sense of satisfaction that can only be shared with others that have survived the same circumstances. Singleton parents have no idea. I only began to fall deeply in love with my kids once they were out of diapers, could feed themselves and talk. Now that I have two five year olds, it's a wonderful time. Now, just ask me again when they're 13 and tell me I'm an idiot, LOL.
 
But the story has nothing to do with abortion.

That was the point. LOL

She didn't have an abortion, yet she still has psychological issues with her life.

The point really is that psychological problems happen regardless whether people choose to have an abortion or not, its called life.
 

Back
Top